|
Researcher's cloning
techniques hold promise in human medicine
By Dale Dombrowski
Photos by Sarah Huff Burnley,
University of Tennessee and Charles Brooks
Photography
Sunday drives through the country often are spent passing
through tranquil areas with ducks swimming on blue-green
ponds and cows grazing in rolling fields. While this
placid scene is common throughout the country, it might
very well take on a different meaning if the cows grazing
in the fields were walking pharmaceutical factories,
capable of producing pharmaceutical proteins.
The concept is not as far-fetched as one might imagine,
especially if you know Mississippi State alumna Lannett
Edwards ('92). Edwards grew up in Houston County,
Tenn., where her grandparents owned a dairy farm. It was
her time on the farm and her love for animals that shaped
her future.
While she was in high school, Edwards participated in 4-H
and was a member of the crop judging team. After
graduation, she went to Austin Peay State University to
study agriculture. At Austin Peay, she took a class in
reproduction in farm animals taught by Dr. Gaines Hunt,
who had earned a doctorate from MSU's College of
Agriculture and Home Economics in 1971. It was in
Hunt's class that she found the direction her career
would follow.
"I really became interested in the subject when I
took Dr. Hunt's repro class," explained Edwards.
"I found that I loved the topic and it was his
guidance that led me to pursue a master's degree at
Mississippi State.
"At MSU, Dr. John Fuquay and Dr. Nancy Cox really
helped me learn so many of the principles I needed for
building a foundation necessary for a career in
academics," said Edwards.
Edwards, who received her master's in dairy science
from MSU and a doctorate from the University of Florida,
is working to identify the importance of animal genes as
they may be involved in reproduction, embryo development,
or disease resistance.
A research assistant professor in the department of animal
science at the University of Tennessee, Edwards became
involved with the sometimes controversial topic of cloning
after moving to the U.S. Department of Agriculture's
Beltsville, Md., facility to do post-doctoral work
following graduation.
"I worked in the USDA's gene evaluation and
mapping lab," said Edwards. "My supervisors, Dr.
Caird Rexroad and Dr. Vernon Pursel, knew Dr. Ian Wilmut
of Scotland, who had encouraged them to send someone over
there to learn cloning procedures. He had been telling
them that we should be able to use cloning to produce the
transgenic livestock we wanted.
"I went to Scotland in the fall after Dolly, the
first-ever clone of an adult sheep, was announced,"
said Edwards. "I was to learn the cloning procedures
and get them up and running in our laboratory so we could
use them as a tool to genetically modify livestock. Dr.
Wilmut invited me to spend two months working with him and
his colleagues in their lab at the Roslin Institute."
By arriving in Scotland when she did in 1966, Edwards
stepped into the middle of the furor.
"I think everything sort of caught him by surprise
initially because people had claimed that this was
biologically impossible," she said. "All of the
developmental biology textbooks and journals said so.
Dolly caught us by surprise, as well as the rest of the
world."
Edwards characterized Wilmut as a humble man, who loved
science.
"He was a very busy man at the time I was there
because at the time, 'Dollymania' had just broken
out and he was inundated with requests," said
Edwards. "His lab-oratory was the first to
successfully clone an adult animal."
"Dolly's DNA originated from a mammary cell
obtained from the udder of a Finn Dorset ewe," said
Edwards. "This DNA was introduced into an egg in
which the nuclear DNA had been removed. The resulting
cloned embryo began to develop and ultimately was
transferred into a Scottish Blackface ewe, which was
Dolly's surrogate mother."
The sheep we know as Dolly is a clone of a six-year old
ewe. And, while her birth rewrote the developmental
biology texts and made scientists rethink positions on the
subject of cloning, it was the announcement of a second
clone-Polly-that was even more interesting because of the
possibilities it presented.
"On the last day of my visit to Scotland, they
announced the birth of Polly, who was the first
transgenic-or genetically modified-sheep that was made
using the cloning process," said Edwards. "She
is a unique animal in the sense that the scientists
inserted a gene that will be targeted to be expressed in
the mammary glands, so when she begins to lactate, her
milk should contain a human blood clotting factor."
Polly has shown that it is possible to genetically modify
farm animals using cloning procedures for the purpose of
producing non-traditional commodities.
"What attracts most people's attention is that
genetically modified animals have the ability to produce
pharmaceutical proteins," she explained. "Some
of these proteins are available now to help treat human
disease, but they cost several million dollars and the
cost alone prohibits them from being available to the
general public.
"So if we can get farm animals to produce these
beneficial proteins, this would increase the availability
of drugs in the future," she said. "They're
like little pharmaceutical factories, and are often
referred to as bioreactors."
The cloning process allows researchers to construct a
cloned embryo by taking the DNA from a somatic (body) cell
of the animal to be cloned and transferring it into an egg
cytoplasm (an egg from which the nucleus has been removed)
obtained from another animal like it. The egg cytoplasm
will reprogram the nucleus of a somatic cell and make it
perform as an early embryo.
The result is the formation of a one-cell cloned embryo
that can begin to grow and develop. And, while the process
does work, very few embryos will result in a live birth
following their transfer into surrogate recipients.
"If you started with 100 cloned embryos containing
only one cell, approximately 30 would be expected to
develop in the laboratory over a seven-day period,"
Edwards explained. "If we transferred those 30
surviving cloned embryos into surrogate recipients, at
best only 15-or about 50 percent-would be expected to
establish a pregnancy.
"Based on what others are reporting, only about 25
percent of the cloned embryos successful in establishing a
pregnancy will result in a live offspring," she
continued. "So the overall efficiency of the cloning
procedures ranges from 0.3 to 3 percent based on the
number of embryos you start with, to the number of
offspring you have on the ground at the end of the
process.
"Dolly's announcement changed our way of
thinking," she said. "Dolly demonstrated to
researchers that is was not only possible to clone adult
animals using somatic cells, but given the fact that
somatic cells can be readily grown and genetically
modified in the laboratory, the cloning procedures became
ideal for genetically modifying farm animals. Using
genetically modified somatic cells to produce cloned
offspring will ensure that 100 percent of the resulting
offspring will be genetically modified or have the gene of
interest.
"Using cloning procedures to produce genetically
modified farm animals is an incredible improvement over
the traditional method of choice," she continued.
"With that you can start out with 10,000 one-cell
embryos that you micro-inject with DNA and in one study
only seven of the 10,000 attempts had the gene that
researchers were interested in studying. This method was
inefficient and costly. At the time, it was estimated that
it would cost $500,000 to produce a transgenic farm
animal."
At Beltsville, Edwards was looking for alternative
approaches to producing transgenic livestock, "so we
could study things at the molecular level."
"Clearly, cloning procedures may offer an alternative
approach for producing genetically modified farm
animals," she said.
At UT, Edwards and her research team-which includes her
husband Dr. Neal Schrick and Dr. Steve Oliver-are in the
initial stages of their research.
"We have produced cloned embryos that have
established pregnancies," Edwards said. "We hope
to have our first calf on the ground late this summer.
These first embryos that we have implanted are not
genetically modified."
The research is new at UT, and this is Edwards'
initial attempt to show potential funding agencies that
she has a technique that will work.
And, the fact that the research is being done with dairy
cows is important for two reasons.
"First, we want to see if we can identify specific
genes that will help prevent certain diseases in dairy
cattle," said Edwards. "To do so, we will use
cloning procedures to genetically modify the cattle to
determine the importance of a gene in conferring disease
resistance to mastitis, an inflammation of the mammary
gland that reduces the ability of a cow to produce
milk."
A second goal is to find out why so many of the embryos
that form die soon after conception.
"If we can begin to solve some of the problems and
why embryos die, we can figure out ways to improve their
overall chances of survival," said Edwards.
She said the team will use the cloning process as a tool
to study the importance of genes during early embryo
development.
Edwards said her husband is a vital member of the team.
"Essentially, what I do is make the clones," she
said. "I collect the cells from the animals we want
to clone with, do the cloning procedures, and grow them in
the laboratory for a period of seven days.
"Neal's expertise is embryo transfer. He takes
the cloned embryos that I have been growing in the lab and
non-surgically transfers them into surrogate recipient
animals," she explained. "We work incredibly
well as a team because-without his level of expertise-I
could produce all the embryos I wanted in the laboratory,
but if I couldn't transfer them in the most optimum
way, I wouldn't get pregnancies.
"Neal is experienced in ultrasonography and we are
doing an ultrasound in every established pregnancy at
two-week intervals so we can evaluate the pregnancy and
determine the viability of the embryo," she said.
Using technology to create cloned animals has caused
scientists, researchers, and many others to take a long,
hard look at some very difficult ethical issues. One
particular issue that stirs many emotions is whether
scientists and researchers are playing God by tampering
with natural reproduction processes.
"If you look back to when new technologies and
processes became available that people didn't
understand, in many instances you'll find there was an
outcry against these technologies and processes,"
Edwards said.
She points to the in vitro fertilization process as a
prime example.
"When people were first made aware of in vitro
fertilization, there was an outcry about the process, but
today it is a socially acceptable practice," Edwards
said.
She does not think scientists are playing God by cloning
farm animals, however.
"I think God has given us a brain to use and to
exercise-to explore and to develop our knowledge
pertaining to the processes of life-and that is what we
are doing," she said. "I believe we are using
tools that God gave us, but in my opinion, without Him
there would be no creation."
She takes a totally different stand on the concept of
cloning a human being.
"I find the idea of cloning humans totally
repulsive," she said. "I can't think of any
reason, other than selfish ones, why anyone would ever
conceive of doing such a thing."
Edwards doesn't believe the idea of clones should be
foreign to people.
"Some people will be forever against the idea of
using cloning procedures for the betterment of mankind,
but, if you think about it, the idea of cloning is not new
because identical twins are nature's truest form of a
clone."
|